John Payne averages 6.97 across 10 rated films as an actor, ahead of Dan Duryea at 6.92.
Dot size shows IMDb votes. Films with fewer than 1,000 votes sit on the baseline.
| Larceny | 1948 | 6.8 | as Silky Randall | as Rick Maxon |
| Rails Into Laramie | 1954 | · | as Jim Shanessy | as Jefferson Harder |
| Silver Lode | 1954 | 6.8 | as Fred McCarty | as Dan Ballard |
