Gordon MacRae averages 6.66 across 7 rated films as an actor, ahead of Doris Day at 6.60.
Dot size shows IMDb votes. Films with fewer than 1,000 votes sit on the baseline.
| Tea for Two | 1950 | 6.5 | as Nanette Carter | as Jimmy Smith |
| The West Point Story | 1950 | 6.2 | as Jan Wilson | as Tom Fletcher |
| On Moonlight Bay | 1951 | 6.9 | as Marjorie Winfield | as William Sherman |
| Starlift | 1951 | · | as Doris Day | as Gordon MacRae |
| By the Light of the Silvery Moon | 1953 | 7.0 | as Marjorie Winfield | as Bill Sherman |
