Claudette Colbert averages 7.01 across 25 rated films as an actor, ahead of Fred MacMurray at 6.77.
Dot size shows IMDb votes. Films with fewer than 1,000 votes sit on the baseline.
| The Bride Comes Home | 1935 | · | as Jeannette Desmereau | as Cyrus Anderson |
| The Gilded Lily | 1935 | 6.7 | as Marilyn David | as Peter Dawes |
| Maid of Salem | 1937 | · | as Barbara Clarke | as Roger Coverman of Virginia |
| No Time for Love | 1943 | 6.7 | as Katherine Grant | as Jim Ryan |
| The Egg and I | 1947 | 6.9 | as Betty | as Bob |
| Family Honeymoon | 1948 | · | as Katie Armstrong Jordan | as Grant Jordan |
