Donald Crisp averages 7.00 across 44 rated films as an actor, ahead of Alan Hale at 6.87.
Dot size shows IMDb votes. Films with fewer than 1,000 votes sit on the baseline.
| The Little Minister | 1934 | · | as Rob Dow | as Doctor McQueen |
| The Sisters | 1938 | 6.8 | as Sam Johnson | as Tim Hazelton |
| Valley of the Giants | 1938 | · | as 'Ox' Smith | as Andy Stone |
| The Private Lives of Elizabeth and Essex | 1939 | 7.0 | as Earl of Tyrone | as Francis Bacon |
 The Sea Hawk | 1940 | 7.6 | as Carl Pitt | as Sir John Burleson |
| The Adventures of Mark Twain | 1944 | 7.1 | as Steve Gillis | as J.B. Pond |
