Critics vs crowd: romance films of all time | Cinemuse

Metascore well above the IMDb rating

Critics loved it, the crowd didn't

Critics vs crowd: romance films of all time: Critics loved it, the crowd didn't
#
1	Carol	2015	94	73	21
2	Three Colors: Red	1994	100	80	20
3	Sideways	2004	94	75	19
4	Licorice Pizza	2021	90	71	19
5	Vertigo	1958	100	82	18
6	My Fair Lady	1964	95	77	18
7	Anora	2024	91	74	17
8	Knocked Up	2007	85	69	16
9	Call Me by Your Name	2017	94	78	16
10	Some Like It Hot	1959	98	82	16
11	Singin' in the Rain	1952	99	83	16
12	Past Lives	2023	94	78	16
13	Phantom Thread	2017	90	74	16
14	The Kids Are All Right	2010	86	70	16
15	Casablanca	1942	100	85	15
16	Marriage Story	2019	94	79	15
17	Gone with the Wind	1939	97	82	15
18	Before Midnight	2013	94	79	15
19	Portrait of a Lady on Fire	2019	95	80	15
20	The Shape of Water	2017	87	73	14
21	Little Women	2019	91	77	14
22	City Lights	1931	99	85	14
23	Blue Is the Warmest Colour	2013	90	76	14
24	Hit Man	2023	82	68	14
25	The Worst Person in the World	2021	91	77	14

IMDb rating well above the Metascore

The crowd loved it, critics didn't

Critics vs crowd: romance films of all time: The crowd loved it, critics didn't
#
1	Collateral Beauty	2016	23	68	45
2	A Walk to Remember	2002	35	73	38
3	Van Wilder	2002	26	64	38
4	Good Luck Chuck	2007	19	56	37
5	The Ugly Truth	2009	28	64	36
6	A Cinderella Story	2004	25	60	35
7	Mr. Deeds	2002	24	58	34
8	Blended	2014	31	65	34
9	The Bounty Hunter	2010	22	56	34
10	Killers	2010	21	55	34
11	Safe Haven	2013	34	67	33
12	This Means War	2012	31	63	32
13	The Phantom of the Opera	2004	40	72	32
14	Leap Year	2010	33	65	32
15	Just Go with It	2011	33	64	31
16	P.S. I Love You	2007	39	70	31
17	Remember Me	2010	40	71	31
18	Bride Wars	2009	24	55	31
19	Flipped	2010	45	76	31
20	Legends of the Fall	1994	45	75	30
21	Passengers	2016	41	70	29
22	Meet Joe Black	1998	43	72	29
23	Where the Crawdads Sing	2022	43	72	29
24	Mallrats	1995	41	70	29
25	My Name Is Khan	2010	50	79	29

Critics vs crowd: romance films of all time | Cinemuse