Critics vs crowd: mystery films of all time | Cinemuse

Metascore well above the IMDb rating

Critics loved it, the crowd didn't

Critics vs crowd: mystery films of all time: Critics loved it, the crowd didn't
#
1	Notorious	1946	100	79	21
2	Three Colors: Red	1994	100	80	20
3	Under the Skin	2013	82	63	19
4	Winter's Bone	2010	90	71	19
5	Citizen Kane	1941	100	82	18
6	Vertigo	1958	100	82	18
7	The Babadook	2014	86	68	18
8	Gosford Park	2001	90	72	18
9	Rashomon	1950	98	81	17
10	It Comes at Night	2017	78	61	17
11	Rear Window	1954	100	84	16
12	North by Northwest	1959	98	82	16
13	The Third Man	1949	97	81	16
14	The Blair Witch Project	1999	80	65	15
15	It Follows	2014	83	68	15
16	Ad Astra	2019	80	65	15
17	X	2022	80	65	15
18	Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy	2011	85	70	15
19	Hereditary	2018	87	73	14
20	The Birds	1963	90	76	14
21	Solaris	1972	93	79	14
22	Us	2019	81	68	13
23	Pig	2021	82	69	13
24	Psycho	1960	97	85	12
25	Longlegs	2024	77	65	12

IMDb rating well above the Metascore

The crowd loved it, critics didn't

Critics vs crowd: mystery films of all time: The crowd loved it, critics didn't
#
1	8MM	1999	21	66	45
2	The Life of David Gale	2003	31	75	44
3	Friday the 13th	1980	22	63	41
4	Seven Pounds	2008	36	76	40
5	Pandorum	2009	28	67	39
6	Case 39	2009	25	62	37
7	Silent Hill	2006	31	65	34
8	Clue	1985	41	73	32
9	Saw VI	2009	30	61	31
10	The Unforgivable	2021	41	72	31
11	Saw 3D	2010	24	55	31
12	Self/less	2015	34	65	31
13	Saw	2004	46	76	30
14	Primal Fear	1996	47	77	30
15	National Treasure	2004	40	69	29
16	Where the Crawdads Sing	2022	43	72	29
17	Fractured	2019	36	65	29
18	Orphan	2009	42	70	28
19	Basic Instinct	1992	43	71	28
20	The Best Offer	2013	49	77	28
21	Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me	1992	45	73	28
22	Ghost Ship	2002	28	56	28
23	Dead Silence	2007	34	62	28
24	Mr. Brooks	2007	45	72	27
25	The Jacket	2005	44	71	27

Critics vs crowd: mystery films of all time | Cinemuse