Film board

Critics vs crowd: family films of all time

When

Genre

Min votes

Films with both scores

426

1K+ votes each

Within 5 points

26%

of the 400 most voted

Metascore against IMDb ratingIMDb x 10 higherMetascore higher

Metascore well above the IMDb rating

Critics loved it, the crowd didn't

Critics vs crowd: family films of all time: Critics loved it, the crowd didn't
#
1	Snow White	2025	50	22	28
2	The Three Caballeros	1944	85	62	23
3	Flight of the Red Balloon	2007	86	65	21
4	Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs	1937	96	76	20
5	Fantasia	1940	96	77	19
6	Meet Me in St. Louis	1944	94	75	19
7	Free Willy	1993	79	61	18
8	Peter Pan & Wendy	2023	61	44	17
9	Little Fugitive	1953	91	75	16
10	Beauty and the Beast	1991	95	80	15
11	Babe	1995	83	69	14
12	The Farewell	2019	89	75	14
13	Little Women	1994	87	73	14
14	E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial	1982	92	79	13
15	Sleeping Beauty	1959	85	72	13
16	The Little Mermaid	1989	88	76	12
17	Cinderella	1950	85	73	12
18	The Munsters	2022	57	45	12
19	The Water Man	2020	68	56	12
20	WALL·E	2008	95	84	11
21	The Wizard of Oz	1939	92	81	11
22	Stuart Little 2	2002	66	55	11
23	The Red Turtle	2016	86	75	11
24	20,000 Leagues Under the Sea	1954	83	72	11
25	Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret.	2023	84	73	11

IMDb rating well above the Metascore

Critics vs crowd: family films of all time: The crowd loved it, critics didn't
#
1	Nine Lives	2016	11	53	42
2	Home	2009	47	85	38
3	A Cinderella Story	2004	25	60	35
4	Christmas with the Kranks	2004	22	56	34
5	War of the Buttons	1962	41	74	33
6	Jumanji	1995	39	71	32
7	Dilili in Paris	2018	37	68	31
8	Dolittle	2020	26	56	30
9	The Christmas Candle	2013	33	63	30
10	The Art of Getting By	2011	36	65	29
11	Major Payne	1995	34	63	29
12	Simon Birch	1998	39	68	29
13	Alice Through the Looking Glass	2016	34	62	28
14	Bedtime Stories	2008	33	61	28
15	The Spy Next Door	2010	27	55	28
16	Problem Child	1990	27	55	28
17	The Perfect Man	2005	27	55	28
18	Playing with Fire	2019	24	52	28
19	Annie	1982	39	66	27
20	Hocus Pocus	1993	43	69	26
21	The Garbage Pail Kids Movie	1987	1	27	26
22	The King of Kings	2025	42	68	26
23	A Week Away	2021	32	58	26
24	The Black Stallion Returns	1983	34	60	26
25	Return to Oz	1985	42	67	25