Film board

Critics vs crowd: animated films of all time

When

Genre

Min votes

Films with both scores

200

100K+ votes each

Within 5 points

43%

of the 200 most voted

Metascore against IMDb ratingIMDb x 10 higherMetascore higher

Metascore well above the IMDb rating

Critics loved it, the crowd didn't

Critics vs crowd: animated films of all time: Critics loved it, the crowd didn't
#
1	Pinocchio	1940	99	74	25
2	Dumbo	1941	96	72	24
3	Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs	1937	96	76	20
4	Fantasia	1940	96	77	19
5	Bambi	1942	91	73	18
6	The Boy and the Heron	2023	91	73	18
7	Chicken Run	2000	88	71	17
8	Ratatouille	2007	96	81	15
9	Beauty and the Beast	1991	95	80	15
10	Turning Red	2022	83	69	14
11	Toy Story	1995	96	83	13
12	Inside Out	2015	94	81	13
13	Happy Feet	2006	77	64	13
14	Sleeping Beauty	1959	85	72	13
15	The Little Mermaid	1989	88	76	12
16	Cinderella	1950	85	73	12
17	Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit	2005	87	75	12
18	WALL·E	2008	95	84	11
19	Spirited Away	2001	96	86	10
20	The Incredibles	2004	90	80	10
21	One Hundred and One Dalmatians	1961	83	73	10
22	Ponyo	2008	86	76	10
23	Persepolis	2007	90	80	10
24	Toy Story 3	2010	92	83	9
25	Toy Story 2	1999	88	79	9

IMDb rating well above the Metascore

Critics vs crowd: animated films of all time: The crowd loved it, critics didn't
#
1	R.I.P.D.	2013	25	56	31
2	Pixels	2015	27	56	29
3	Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles	2014	31	58	27
4	Hotel Transylvania	2012	47	71	24
5	The Super Mario Bros. Movie	2023	46	70	24
6	The Smurfs	2011	30	54	24
7	Sing 2	2021	49	73	24
8	Hotel Transylvania 2	2015	44	66	22
9	Brother Bear	2003	48	69	21
10	The Angry Birds Movie	2016	43	63	20
11	Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs	2009	50	69	19
12	Robin Hood	1973	57	75	18
13	The Lorax	2012	46	64	18
14	The Road to El Dorado	2000	51	69	18
15	Klaus	2019	65	82	17
16	Atlantis: The Lost Empire	2001	52	69	17
17	The Croods	2013	55	71	16
18	Ice Age: Continental Drift	2012	49	65	16
19	Fantastic Four	2015	27	43	16
20	Ice Age	2002	61	75	14
21	Rise of the Guardians	2012	58	72	14
22	Despicable Me 3	2017	49	63	14
23	Penguins of Madagascar	2014	53	67	14
24	Epic	2013	52	66	14
25	Rio 2	2014	49	63	14